Room Cost Reduced 60%! Now Only $40,000
“If you think PPO programs save you money, rethink and ask yourself, compared to what? The average national PPO pays hospitals over 250% of Medicare. It will get worse next year and the year after when annual PPO-Hospital escalator clauses go into effect. PPO’s are a contract to overpay for healthcare services!”
What do cars and hotel rooms have to do with healthcare benefits, maybe a lot!
Research and Patience
As an anniversary gift to my wife, I recently bought her a Jeep Wrangler. There are over a dozen Jeep dealers in my area, and I perused all of their websites. I also looked online at Jeep dealers well outside our home market and even those that could be delivered to me. My goal was simple, get the most car for my money. I drove past the three closest dealerships and haggled for three days before finally buying her Jeep. The research and expanding my purchase circle probably saved me about $1,500 on about a $32,000 purchase.
Cost Only $25 Co-Pay!
When our employees travel, they are required to spend our company’s money prudently relative to hotel rooms, rental cars, and meals. I recognize that we are uprooting them from their homes, probably causing them to miss functions for themselves or their children, and creating the discomfort that present day travel entails. Regardless, we don’t allow excessive expenditures on travel expenses. The extra hundred or more dollars that can be saved per trip with a little research on-line goes right back to our bottom line at the end of the day and helps support higher salaries, more hiring, bonuses, and the perpetuation of our business. Only a handful of our employees travel, but the money they save on trips benefit everyone.
I am sure that everyone reading this article acts and reacts the same way. When spending our hard earned money, most of us are prudent especially when the item we are buying is expensive. I would have gladly driven another 50-100 miles had I found that same Jeep another five hundred to one-thousand dollars cheaper. When I travel myself, I aggressively compare hotel rates through multiple on-line travel sites before settling on the best value (quality/price) before committing.
- Why is it then that basically every employer in America has absolutely no requirements for prudent buying behavior on their group health insurance plans? Further, why do employee/members on those plans not manage a plan’s co-mingled money the way they would their own money? The answer to these questions typically range from uninformed to absurd.
‘Less than 1% of CEO/CFOs provide incentives to manage expenditures frugally’
Let’s start with the employer side and at the top. I would venture that less than 1% of CEO/CFOs in America provide any incentive whatsoever for the people who run their human resource departments to manage expenditures frugally. I would further wager that an even smaller number tie bonuses or incentives to creating value enhancing cost management programs. Rather, senior executives, at least give the impression, that no news is good news from their HR team and hope to spend as little time as possible involved in that function. This is nonsensical when we recognize that employee benefits are typically the second highest cost item for companies in the service business (after payroll) and the third largest expense for manufacturing companies (after payroll and COGS).
Employer: “I’m Sorry, I just can’t give you a raise after paying for your health insurance!”
According to a study published by The National Conference of State Legislatures, the cost of healthcare per employee in 2016 was $18,142. Compare this to a cost of $13,375 just six years ago. Beyond the fact that the ACA is a miserable failure relative to its goal of reducing the cost of care by having more people covered, this is also a reprimand to employers who have continued to do nothing outside the norm in finding a way to control their own health insurance expenditures. The same employers who scratch and claw fanatically at other business expenses just look at healthcare costs like a deer in the headlights not knowing or taking the time to learn that plan changes and external services exist that will promote cost reductions of 5% up to as much as 30%. Consider those numbers for a moment.
- Let’s say an employer with 500 employees on their healthcare plan and spending the national average lowers their cost of healthcare services by just 10%. Assuming the average noted above of $18,142 per employee that 10% savings amount to annual savings of $907,000 annually which goes straight to the company’s bottom line. To make that number more meaningful, assume that the company values itself for innumerous reasons at 8X Cash Flow/ EBITDA. The business market value of that savings is thus $7,256,000.
A Few Considerations: Here are some thoughts that will help you cut your health insurance costs.
- If you think PPO programs save you money, rethink and ask yourself, compared to what? The average national PPO pays hospitals over 250% of Medicare. It will get worse next year and the year after when annual PPO-Hospital escalator clauses go into effect. PPO’s are a contract to overpay for healthcare services!
- If you are dealing with BC/BS, Aetna, Cigna, United, and some TPAs, check out what you are paying to manage out-of-network claims. Many times companies are charged more for managing the ~7% of claims that fall out-of-network than they are to manage in- network claims. Let me state this clearly; it is highly likely you are being robbed here.
- Independent TPAs often do a much better job of managing an employer’s claims than the ASO carriers (Blue, Aetna, United, Cigna, etc.) yet they are often half the cost.
- The big carrier insurance companies have a clause in your contracts that you have likely glossed over. The clause provides that they can do external audits on their payments to hospitals or physicians at their discretion. Sounds OK, right? Wrong. Read the clause carefully; they can do so at their discretion and as long as you are still a client if they find overpayment they will return 65% of your money to you while the ASO keeps the other 35%….as long as you are a client. If you are no longer a client, they often keep all the recovery.
- The item above gets worse when you consider that the ASO administrators do almost no diligence on an employer’s claims before they pay them. NO MATTER HOW LARGE THE CLAIM IS. Yep, if you have a $1 million dollar claim, it is very likely that Blue, Cigna, Aetna, United, all of them, just wrote a check with your and or your stop loss carriers money without doing any reasonable diligence WHATSOEVER.
- Put the last two items together, your trusted insurance carrier/ ASO, does not look at your claims before paying them. They then, occasionally, audit the hospitals and physicians to whom they made the payment with your money. If they find that they over-paid, which is almost always the case, they get to keep 35% of the recovery.
The opportunity for your company to lower your cost of healthcare by 10%-25% without affecting the quality or quantity of services is immediately available.
About The Author
Mike Dendy is Vice Chairman & CEO of Atlanta, GA based Advanced Medical Pricing Solutions (AMPS), a healthcare cost management company, serving the self-funded (ERISA) payer community. Since joining the Company in 2005, Mr. Dendy has overseen all aspects of AMPS, ranging from sales and marketing, to finance and client relations.
Before joining AMPS, Mike served as Chairman & CEO of HPS Paradigm Administrators Inc. from 1997 until its subsequent sale in 2004. HPS Paradigm is a health insurance Third-Party Administrator (TPA) serving corporate and government employer groups throughout the United States. During his tenure as CEO, HPS Paradigm experienced strong corporate growth, increasing on average 50 percent in fee income per year, while achieving industry leading EBITDA margins of over 22 percent. In 2000, Mike oversaw HPS’ business process outsourcing (BPO) relationship with Memorial Hospital of Savannah, Georgia which at the time was one of Georgia’s largest hospital systems. Mike served as executive director of Memorial’s TPA, HMO, PPO, UR/UM and Case Management services provided for the benefit of Chatham County employers.
From 1992-1997, Mike founded and managed Health Partners Services, Inc. (HPS), a brokerage and consulting firm, which specialized in stop-loss insurance, benefit plan design, provider negotiations, pharmacy benefit management, disease management, predictive analysis, and cost containment. HPS developed community health system plans in many southeastern U.S. markets. Visit advancedpricing.com.